What the Planned Parenthood Stings don’t show

In Portland we’ve seen a little of the anti-abortion activism that goes on in this country, but only a small amount. I remember driving by the empty space on Martin Luther King Boulevard where a Planned Parenthood was going to be put in and seeing a small group of people protesting with their picket signs. And from time to time I would also see them on Fremont and 15th, near an already opened Planned Parenthood. This was already scary enough to me, to see people simply protesting against an organization that I really like.

The recent sting operations against Planned Parenthood definitely scare me more, and this is the second time something like this has happened to them.

Just this January, an anti-abortion group called Live Action had 12 men acting as pimps go into Planned Parenthoods in 6 different states and ask about receiving medical care, birth control and abortions for their prostitutes, giving ages as young as fourteen. The experiences the men had were recorded. Two videos have been released since, though analysis shows they were doctored before being released. One Planned Parenthood Manager in one video was fired for her upsetting behavior and comments that were recorded, while the other woman recorded is said to have accurately represented Planned Parenthood’s values. Live Action is trying to “expose” Planned Parenthood for breaking state and federal laws and for covering up abuse against young girls that the organization says they protect. They are ultimately trying to cut Planned Parenthood’s funding.

To read a full article on the situation, go here. You can also read about Live Action, the doctoring of the tapes, and Planned Parenthood’s reaction on their website here.

This extreme scenario of trying to access services for underage prostitutes is a perfect way to get Planned Parenthood in trouble – one wrong word in a situation like this and you are the bad guy. It’s also perfect because it would be making them out to be abusing a group of people they want to protect, young women being coerced into prostitution. This is harassment against individual workers, however, not a productive way to fight Planned Parenthood’s values. Instead of gaining social momentum and using people as power behind their movement, they are using shallow tactics to try to disrupt or end Planned Parenthood. Also, since the videos were edited, then who knows how the exchange even happened? It’s clear that what occurred in these videos do not represent what Planned Parenthood truly stands for. As for the manager that got fired, it is quite unfortunate she acted the way she did (though again, it would be useful to see the unedited footage), and her firing is an appropriate response. Planned Parenthood reacted quickly and how their supporters would want them to, showing they are still protecting their own values.

This is a different approach to undermining and trying to exterminate Planned Parenthood, one that is scarier than protesters. What else are these groups willing to do to end this organization? And what does it mean to eliminate funding for Planned Parenthood? It means taking away a huge resource for women, for men, for young people, for us. I use Planned Parenthood’s services, as do many of my friends. I knew the name Planned Parenthood before I ever knew what birth control was. Threatening a leader organization in reproductive rights is expected, but it doesn’t mean it’s not scary. Planned Parenthood stands for so much to so many people; this is a threat to more than the workers that were recorded and the specific locations that were targeted. This is a threat to the entire movement of reproductive rights, healthy sexuality, and access to cheap, safe and affordable reproductive healthcare.

To me this was a reminder that I need to protect Planned Parenthood and organizations like it when I can. As established as Planned Parenthood may seem, there are those who still fight against them. I don’t want to fight against the fighters, but I want to protect what they are attacking.

What does Planned Parenthood mean to you? What would it mean if these sting operations were ever powerful enough to affect their funding? What can you do to protect things like Planned Parenthood? Remember to vote if you can, and take action through volunteering and talking with your peers.


Angela Carkner



2 thoughts on “What the Planned Parenthood Stings don’t show

  1. The Anti Abortion protesters, are Anti Life. We have a right to choose our directions in life. They want to strip women of their personal rights. They kill doctors and inocent people under the name of their savior Jesus Christ. The anti abortion protestors sent my son to Iraq to kill inocent babies, children, mothers and fathers for a false war that President Bush and Dick Chaneye made up. Anyone who kills in the name of Christ is of the devil himself. You anti abortion protestors are the anti Christ. You stalk people, you harass people because they are not of the simple backward minds of yourself. You set out to strip American Women of their freedoms and rights to a very good health care systems. You Anti Abortion Protestors are of the same mind as the Teliaban. Do you call yourselves the GOD Sqad? Who made you judge over the American Womans body? Anti Abortion protestors are hypocrites of your own kind. They say they want less government, but on the same breath, they say they want the government to tell Woman, what they can do to their bodies. If you are Anti abortion and truly worship Jesus Christ as your savior, you shall only judge your own mortality and not your neighbors. Pick the bean out of your own eys, before you pick the speck out of your neighbors eye. Let the one without sin cast the first stone. You are not here to judge the world, but you must judge yourself with the eyes as you have judge others. For the Love of Woman and mankind and babies, keep your Religious beliefs in your own minds and hearts. Do Not play GOD of the World. Think of pease. Take some food to a poor and hungry family. That baby that didn’t get aborted cloth it. Take on a foster family that you can financially help. Put your energys into the living not the dead. God is not your roll to play. Life is what it is. So let’s make the most of it.

  2. You make some interesting points. I do not totally agree with what you had to say, but I wanted to say thanks for your response. It’s great to hear all perspectives on this matter.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out /  Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s